We offer cake tastings & design consultations either in-person or as to-go boxes that can be picked up at our Atlantic Highlands location.
If you would like to schedule a tasting, please fill out our “Create Your Cake” form first - if you haven’t done so already.


We typically schedule tastings on weekend mornings [9:00 am - 12:30 pm] or weekdays [12:00 - 5:30 pm], but we try to accommodate all schedules. However, appointments are limited - please let us know if you would prefer a weekday or weekend tasting. The more advanced notice we have, the more flexible we can be with scheduling. Duration: Approximately 30 minutes.

You may bring up to 3 additional guests with you (4 total attending). Please let us know how many will be attending so we can prepare.


To confirm your tasting reservation, payment must be made in advance. We accept Venmo (@thevintagecake), PayPal, Chase QuickPay with Zelle, or a mailed check. If you prefer to pay cash the day-of, we would need a credit card on file to hold the reservation.

Cancellation Policy:

Cancellations received prior to 48 hours of your tasting date will receive a 50% refund.
Cancellations received between 48 hours - 1 week of your tasting date will receive a full refund.


Our address: 171 First Avenue, Suite 7, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716  - We are located on the right hand side of the Oceanic Commons building, to the right of/behind Seabreeze Cleaners, at the very end of the driveway/alley. Please walk all the way down the driveway, we are the last door on the left. There is street parking available on First Avenue and surrounding streets.
*Please note - do not use a car GPS, it will bring you to a residence. Google or iPhone maps will bring you to the correct location.

Please see below for our Tasting Packages Offered

Any package below can be modified to accommodate gluten-free diets for an additional $10.
Alterations to the below selections will incur an additional fee.